Spirit World (영계 / 靈界 / Yeong-gye): The Invisible Co-Dimension of a Single Continuum of Being in Unification Doctrine
Spirit World · The Eternal World · The Heavenly World · The World Above
What Is the Spirit World?
The Spirit World — in Korean 영계 (Yeong-gye), in Hanja 靈界 — is the Unification doctrine that the dwelling place of the departed is not a discontinuous “other world” sealed off from the realm of the living, as both popular Christian piety and secular common sense often assume, but the invisible co-dimension of a single continuum of being.
The physical world (육계, yukgye) and the spirit world together constitute one cosmos: two modes of the same reality, ontologically continuous, in constant reciprocal action, mutually visible at every point, and converging providentially toward a single completed end.
The Spirit World is not a destination remote from earthly life; it is the deeper dimension of the same life one is living right now.
This entry advances a single defensible thesis. I argue that the Spirit World in Unification doctrine is the invisible co-dimension of a single continuum of being, characterized by three load-bearing claims that together distinguish the teaching from every prior religious account of the afterlife: ontological continuity (one cosmos, two modes), absolute transparency (no editing, complete records of every earthly event), and active providential reciprocity (the dead substantively mobilize the living, the living substantively liberate the dead).
Each of these three claims is doctrinally constitutive — strip away any one and the Unification account collapses into a familiar alternative; hold all three together and the doctrine stands as a coherent, distinctive, and pastorally consequential teaching.
The compact early formulation of the continuity thesis appears in Rev. Sun Myung Moon’s 1982 sermon “Before the Presence of God” (하나님의 존전 앞에서, vol. 117, page 307):
The spirit world exists for this world. And this world exists for the eternal world. It is wrong to say that the spirit world does not exist. I am doing this providential work because the spirit world does exist. You may say, “Where in this world is God, and where is the spirit world? I don’t know.” But the spirit world is the place where you find God. What does God exist as? God is true love. His hopes can only be realized through love.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 117-307, 04/11/1982; verified Korean title: 하나님의 존전 앞에서) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The architectural claim is precise. The two worlds are not two; they are one in two modes, each existing for the other, neither finally intelligible apart from the other.
To deny the Spirit World is, in this framework, not merely to deny a fact about the afterlife but to deny the deeper half of present reality.
Etymology: 靈 + 界
The compound 영계 decomposes into two Sino-Korean elements, both heavy with classical East Asian philosophical and religious weight.
靈 (yeong) means spirit, soul, numinous, or divinely efficacious. The character originally pictured a rain-dance shaman invoking divine presence — three small mouths chanting under falling rain — and through that pictographic origin came to denote any reality that mediates between the human and the divine.
In classical Chinese texts, 靈 names not merely “spirit” rather than “matter” but rather the living, animating, numinous reality that gives a thing its power and presence. The ling of a great mountain is its sacred efficacy; the ling of an ancestral spirit is its capacity to bless or affect the descendants; the ling in Daoist and Buddhist usage names the operative numinous force in any sacred encounter.
界 (gye) means realm, world, boundary, or sphere of jurisdiction. The character originally pictured a field (田) with boundaries drawn (介) — the basic image of a bounded region with defined extent and proper governance. In classical usage 界 names not a vague “world” but a structured realm with its own internal order, laws, inhabitants, and rulers. The Buddhist 三界 (three realms — desire, form, formless) and 法界 (Dharma-realm) employ this character precisely because the realms in question are structured cosmoi, not formless infinities.
The full compound 영계 therefore reads with technical precision: the structured realm (界) of the spiritually living, numinous, divinely active (靈). Three philological points deserve emphasis.
First, 영계 is not vague: it is a specific, bounded, structured realm with its own internal order.
Second, 영계 is not necessarily distant: the character 靈 in classical East Asian usage names the numinous as present and active, not as ontologically remote.
Third, the standard English translations “spirit world” and especially “afterlife” risk obscuring this precise structure: the Spirit World is not a generic “beyond” but a specific cosmos with its architecture.
Rev. Moon’s preached corpus uses several Korean terms for the Spirit World, each carrying a slightly different rhetorical weight: 영계 (yeong-gye) is the most common and technical, used in doctrinal exposition; 천상세계 (cheonsang segye, “the world above”) and 영원한 세계 (yeongwonhan segye, “the eternal world”) appear in devotional and liturgical contexts; 내세 (naese, “the next world”) and 저세상 (jeosesang, “that world”) appear in conversational register; the Sinitic compound 천주 (cheonju, “the cosmos”) names the entire continuum of physical and spirit worlds in their unified, intended state.
The Spirit World Is the Invisible Half of a Single Cosmos
The most distinctive structural claim of the Unification doctrine of the Spirit World is the claim of ontological continuity: the spirit world and the physical world do not constitute two cosmoi but two dimensions of one.
This claim distinguishes Unification doctrine from every account of the afterlife that locates the spirit world in some ontologically discontinuous “beyond” — beyond death, beyond the universe, beyond the present age.
Rev. Moon developed the continuity claim with particular clarity in a foundational 1977 sermon delivered at Belvedere Training Center on February 6, “영계와 육계” (Spirit World and Physical World), one of only three pre-1990 sermons in the entire corpus whose title directly names 영계.
The sermon begins with a striking question to the assembly: “Do you know that there is a spirit world? Those who know, raise your hand. And more than knowing, those who have experienced it.” The corpus passage that follows traces the original unity intended by God and the present-day division produced by the Fall:
Where then does the spirit world and physical world become one? The spirit world and physical world were originally meant to be one centered on God’s love. They become one through true love. If, before the Fall, God’s love had been with us, we would have been completely unified people of mind and body — eternally seeing all of heaven and earth, living as luminous human beings throughout the universe. We would have had the right to live on earth as God’s princes and princesses. We would have been able to possess God’s love. The reason I receive persecution is because I know that world. I am not someone who fears death — because I know that world.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 91-005, 02/06/1977; verified Korean title: 영계와 육계) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The structural claim is significant. The two worlds were not created as two separate cosmoi to be later linked; they were created as one unified cosmos in which the spirit world and the physical world function as the two complementary dimensions of a single reality, centered on God’s love.
The Fall did not create the division between the worlds — it introduced the division into what was originally a single continuum. Restoration is therefore not a matter of crossing from one world to another but of reuniting what was always meant to be one.
The structural reciprocity between the two worlds — what Rev. Moon called “mirror movement” — is the practical expression of this ontological continuity.
The 1991 lecture to all-American leaders delivered at Belvedere on April 16 (Korean: 전미 지도자 회의 지시 말씀) puts the principle in its most condensed form:
The two worlds move facing each other. If the physical world ascends, so does the spirit world, and if the physical world descends, the spirit world goes down too. If one turns, the other does likewise. You have to realize this point during your life on earth and live in a way that enhances your eternal life. Eternal life and the present world are not separate.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 217-085, 04/16/1991; verified Korean title: 전미 지도자 회의 지시 말씀) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The mirror movement claim has substantial practical consequences. Every act of love on earth has a direct effect in the spirit world. Every prayer offered on earth mobilizes spirits in the spirit world. Every providential breakthrough achieved on earth opens corresponding doors in the spirit world.
The reciprocal also holds: shifts in the spirit world create corresponding influences on earth, particularly when aligned with God’s providential will. The two worlds are not in causal isolation; they are in continuous mutual causation, like the two prongs of a tuning fork striking against one another.
The 2002 sermon “영계와 지상세계는 하나” delivered in Kodiak, Alaska, on August 21, 2002, makes the ontological-continuity thesis perhaps its sharpest formulation in the entire corpus:
Therefore, you must know that the spirit world and earth are not two but one. The eyes that see were meant to see both. You should have eyes that serve God spiritually and True Parents physically, and that can see both worlds. But because of the Fall, the world of the eye is lost. Why? Because true love is the world of the eye — and only when true love is reconnected, will resurrection unfold and the path open to perceive both the earthly world and the heavenly world.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 391-005, 08/21/2002; verified Korean title: 영계와 지상세계는 하나) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The teaching makes precise an anthropological consequence of the ontological continuity thesis. The human eye was originally designed to see both worlds — to perceive the physical reality simultaneously before it and the spiritual reality interpenetrating it.
The capacity for double perception is not a special gift bestowed on a few mystics but the original endowment of every human being. The Fall did not destroy this capacity; it occluded it.
What is lost when the Fall is overcome is therefore not a special intuition added on top of ordinary sight but the recovery of what ordinary sight was always meant to be: stereoscopic perception of a single reality in its two dimensions.
The Spirit World Has No Editing: Perfect Transparency and Complete Records
The second load-bearing claim of the Unification doctrine of the Spirit World — and the one whose pastoral force is most distinctive — is the claim of absolute transparency: in the Spirit World, there is no editing, no concealment, no possibility of presenting a curated version of one’s life.
Every earthly event is recorded with complete fidelity. Every motivation, every secret action, every thought is visible. The Spirit World preserves a substantive record of the entire course of every life that has ever been lived.
Rev. Moon developed this theme with mounting intensity through the late 1980s and 1990s, often using deliberately contemporary technological imagery — videotape, computer files, retrieval codes — to convey the precision and exhaustiveness of the record:
Each action, each expression you make is recorded, as if on a videotape. Can you hide these things in the spirit world? You cannot hide this record, just as you cannot hide what is in your mind. The spirit world is more clearly apparent than the mind and is a place where everything is exposed. There is no use for excuses. You cannot make excuses. The more you open your mouth, the closer your shame before the universe approaches you. You cannot advance in that world. There is only retreat. A fearful age is coming.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong, 11/15/1990) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The metaphor of the videotape is precise in its implications. A videotape captures both image and sound exactly as they occurred, in their full temporal flow, without omission or substitution. When played back, what one sees is what was. There is no possibility of revision, no opportunity to insert a more flattering version.
The Spirit World, according to Rev. Moon’s teaching, holds the videotape of every life, and at the moment of physical death, the videotape begins to play.
The metaphor of the computer carries the same force in a more administrative register. A computer database, when queried, returns the stored record exactly as entered; the record speaks for itself; the subject cannot edit it from outside. Rev. Moon applied this image with striking precision in 1993:
When you go to the spirit world you will find that your life has been completely recorded in the computer there. It will all be revealed. The conscience is like a computer file that is exhibited in the eternal world. Everything is in that file. With the click of a button, all the details of your lifetime, from your time as a baby being held and breastfed by your mother, will be known through the images of your mind. Every day that world is creating a record of your life in order to carry out a complete appraisal of your being. The day for this comes when you die. No one can tell a lie in the presence of that powerful computer that appraises people. The images in the spirit world appear as if in a mirror. Everything is being recorded.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong, 04/16/1993) Cheon Seong Gyeong
Three structural features of the transparency teaching deserve emphasis.
First, the conscience is the recording instrument. The doctrine is not that some external surveillance system catalogs human action; it is that the human conscience itself, embedded within every person, is the recording mechanism. The conscience records continuously throughout life.
What appears in the Spirit World is not an external audit but the conscience’s own complete archive, displayed without filter. This explains why no defense or excuse is possible at the moment of revelation: the testimony is one’s own conscience, and one’s conscience cannot be cross-examined.
Second, the record extends back to infancy. Rev. Moon’s specific image — “from your time as a baby being held and breastfed by your mother” — locates the beginning of the record not at the age of moral accountability but at the very beginning of life. Nothing in the lived life is excluded.
The doctrine does not permit the comforting modern assumption that early life events somehow do not count; they too are recorded, and they too will appear.
Third, the appraisal is mathematical, not discretionary. Rev. Moon used the word “scientific” repeatedly in this context: the Spirit World is mathematical. It moves according to logic. God is the King of scientists. Heaven does not move in any way it likes” (April 15, 1997).
The transparency principle is not vindictive moralism dressed in contemporary metaphor; it is the doctrinal claim that the consequences of earthly life follow with the inevitability of physics because there is finally no concealment.
The pastoral force of this teaching is considerable. In a culture saturated with curated self-presentation — social media, professional personas, the careful management of reputation — the Unification doctrine of the Spirit World says, in effect: the curation ends. The full and uncurated record of the life one has actually lived will be displayed. There is no editing.
This insight has a positive correlate. If the record is complete, then nothing good that was done in secret is lost. The kindness no one saw, the prayer offered in private, the act of love performed without witnesses — these too are in the record.
The transparency works both ways. In June 1998, Rev. Moon stated the principle in one of its clearest single formulations:
Both your spirit self and physical self should be as clear as crystal during your life. You will then have no problems in the spirit world. You cannot enter heaven if there is any kind of flaw. How you live your life on earth is so important. You live in the spirit world as you have lived on this earth. No one is an exception to this. Your entire being is transparently on view.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong, 06/05/1998) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The closing sentence carries the weight of the doctrine: your entire being is transparently on view. Not a sampled excerpt, not a curated highlight reel, not a charitable approximation. The complete being. On view.
This claim resonates with the New Testament teaching that nothing is hidden that shall not be revealed:
For nothing is secret, that shall not be made manifest; neither any thing hid, that shall not be known and come abroad.
The Pauline elaboration in 1 Corinthians develops the same theme in an eschatological register: now we know in part, but at the end of the age we shall know fully, even as we are fully known.
The Unification doctrine of perfect transparency in the Spirit World takes this New Testament teaching and locates its fulfillment not at a future general resurrection but at the moment of each individual’s physical death, when the spirit self crosses into the realm where the conscience’s complete archive is finally displayed.
Love, Not Geography, Is the Spirit World’s Organizing Principle
The Unification doctrine of the Spirit World is structurally a doctrine about love.
The Spirit World is not organized geographically, as a map of regions; it is not organized chronologically, as a queue of arrivals; it is not organized by social rank, as an extension of earthly hierarchy. It is organized by the quality of love each spirit has lived. The 1990 sermon “The Pride of the Unification Church” (vol. 210, page 312) puts the structural claim with precision:
The spirit world is a world of intuition where within a week you can surpass the knowledge of any scholar, however distinguished or great. By seeing things through the light of your heart, you will automatically understand the world and all its related interconnections. This is because from the viewpoint of the heart they are in a certain relationship with you as your subject partner or counterpart.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 210-312, 12/27/1990; verified Korean title: 통일교회의 자랑) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The structural claim is striking. The Spirit World is the realm in which knowledge operates not by discursive analysis (which is the mode of the physical world) but by intuitive perception centered on the heart’s relational engagement. To know something in the Spirit World is to stand in relation to it through love; what one stands in no loving relation to, one cannot understand.
This explains why a person who has lived a life of broad love can, in the Spirit World, swiftly come to understand things that on earth required decades of study: the love-relation itself is the medium of knowing.
The corollary of this teaching is that the position one occupies in the Spirit World is the substantive consequence of the love one has lived on earth. No accumulated wealth transfers. No social status transfers. No academic credential transfers.
Only the quality of love one has actually given and received. This claim has been formulated repeatedly in the corpus; one of its clearest statements appears in the 1991 sermon “Blessing and Resurrection” (축복과 부활):
Once we dwell in the spirit world, through the power of true love we can meet people, however distant, in the twinkling of an eye. And no matter how far away people are, if they are visiting for love, they can travel back to their hometown instantly. The spirit world is limitlessly expansive, but it is also a world in which we can go back and forth instantaneously over infinite distances because of love. Love travels at the highest speed.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 216-192, 03/31/1991; verified Korean title: 축복과 부활) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The teaching reverses the ordinary spatial intuition. In the physical world, distance is measured in meters or miles, and movement is constrained by mass and time.
In the Spirit World, distance is measured in love, and movement is instantaneous wherever the love connection is strong.
Two spirits separated by what would be incalculable physical distance are, in the Spirit World, close — provided love connects them. Two spirits in apparent physical proximity are, in the Spirit World, distant — if no love connects them.
The Structure of the Spirit World Reflects the Structure of the Person
In one of the most striking and easily overlooked teachings of the corpus, Rev. Moon described the Spirit World as structurally isomorphic to the human person.
The Spirit World is not laid out like a map of regions but like the anatomy of a human being — head, trunk, extremities — with God at the center as the mind, and the various dimensions of the cosmos corresponding to the parts of the body. The 1977 sermon “Individual Perfection and God’s Will” (개체완성과 하나님의 뜻) introduces this image:
When you go to the spirit world, you will notice that it resembles a person. As such, it can become one with God, its subject partner. Then the boundary between the entire spirit world and the entire physical world becomes fuzzy. When God jumps, the earth will jump, and when God laughs, so will the earth.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 91-280, 02/27/1977; verified Korean title: 개체완성과 하나님의 뜻) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The structural claim has substantial doctrinal force.
First, it grounds the Unification anthropology: every individual human being who achieves perfection becomes a microcosm of the entire Spirit World. The fully realized person is not merely a part of a larger whole; the fully realized person is structurally isomorphic to the whole.
Second, it grounds the Unification cosmology: the Spirit World is not a vast impersonal expanse but a single great Person — a structured cosmos with its own anatomy, in which different dimensions function as different organs and centers all coordinated by the Heart of God.
Third, it grounds the unity claim of the previous section: when the Spirit World as a Person and God as Subject reach perfect harmony, the boundary between the Spirit World and the physical world dissolves. Heaven and earth move as one.
Rev. Moon described the present-day Spirit World as structurally fourfold in its current fallen-but-being-restored state, drawing on the 2007 sermon “The Time of Attending God First” (하나님을 앞세워서 모시는 때):
The spirit world should be a world that is aligned with the vertical “noontime,” without shadows, bathed in bright sunlight. Instead, it is a mixture of good and bad. It consists of the highest spirit world, the first spirit world, the second spirit world, and the third spirit world. Moreover, different animals live in each of these divisions. In the highest spirit world, animals praise their masters. They are all friends.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 565-239, 06/12/2007; verified Korean title: 하나님을 앞세워서 모시는 때) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The reference to the Spirit World as currently “a mixture of good and bad” is theologically significant. The Spirit World in its present state does not reflect the original ideal: the vertical noontime — sunlight without shadow, the proper ordering of all things in love — has not yet been fully achieved.
The entire structure of the Spirit World is caught up in the providential process of restoration, awaiting completion. It is not a finished creation but a realm in process.
The fourfold present structure — highest, first, second, third — corresponds to gradations of love-realization, with the Kingdom of Heaven (천국, cheonguk) as the highest realm reserved for those who have fulfilled the Three Great Blessings; Paradise (낙원, Nakwon) as the realm of those who lived sincerely but did not realize the Blessing’s full standard, classically associated with Jesus’s own current dwelling; the middle Spirit World as the broad realm of the majority of human spirits across history; and Hell (지옥, jiok) as the lowest realm, where spirits dominated by selfishness and violation dwell in conditions mirroring the nature of the love they rejected.
A distinctive feature of the Unification account is the doctrine that Hell was not created by God. Hell came into being as a consequence of the Fall, as the accumulated weight of unrestored sin required some form of containment. Hell is therefore a tragic necessity, not a divine intention — and the corollary is equally significant: Hell is meant to be liberated. The redemptive work of the Messiah extends to all spirits in the Spirit World, ultimately including those currently in the lowest realm. The teaching is treated in fuller detail in the glossary entry on Hell.
Earthly Life Is the Only Workshop: Why Change Requires the Body
The third load-bearing structural claim of the Unification doctrine of the Spirit World is that change requires the body. The Spirit World is the realm in which the consequences of earthly life are lived out, not the realm in which those consequences are altered.
The decisive workshop in which a spirit grows, repents, indemnifies, and develops is the earthly life. Once the spirit is in the Spirit World, change can come only through reciprocal action with the earthly life of descendants.
This claim has substantial doctrinal force. It explains why earthly life is irreplaceable: there is no second chance, no later opportunity to repair what was not done. It explains the urgency of restoration: the providence of restoration must be completed substantively on earth because the substantive work of love-formation can only be done in the physical body.
It explains the architecture of indemnity: indemnity is paid by living persons, not by spirits, because indemnity requires the substantive offering of the physical body and its choices.
Rev. Moon developed this claim with particular sharpness in a passage from the early 1990s:
Whether human beings like it or not, as the fallen descendants they are destined to surmount the steep pass of indemnity from now, even unto death. No one can deny this. You must traverse this path. If you pass to the spirit world without overcoming this in your lifetime, there is no way to know how many millions of years it will take you in the spirit world. There is no payment of indemnity in the spirit world. It is a liberated realm of perfection filled with the waves of love, so the possibility of indemnity or re-creation does not exist. There is no reproduction either. Since there is no mechanism to stimulate these processes, once you are fixed in a position, it is permanent.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong, 04/12/1992) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The claim is doctrinally precise. The Spirit World is not a realm of repentance or reformation; it is the realm in which the consequences of earthly life are made permanent. The “fixing in position” is not punitive but structural: the Spirit World lacks the substantive machinery — the body, the temporal flow, the encounter with physical situations — by which transformation can occur. The only access to that machinery is through descendants who remain on earth.
This is the doctrinal foundation of the Unification practice of ancestor liberation. The 1986 sermon “Restoration of the Birthright through Indemnity” (장자권 탕감복귀) and its companion “The Blessed Ones” (축복받은 자들) — both delivered February 9, 1986 — develop the structural significance of the living-dead reciprocity:
Though we live in this world, we know that the spirit world also exists. We also know that this world and the spirit world are not separate; they must be connected. Where will we go when we leave the physical world? We are on this earth while we live in the flesh, but we are proceeding toward the eternal world. Our lifetime is merely preparation for the world of eternity.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 140-121, 02/09/1986; verified Korean title: 장자권 탕감복귀 / 축복받은 자들) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The Spirit World in the Three Ages of Providence
The Unification doctrine reads the Spirit World’s history through the same three-age framework that structures its account of providential history more broadly: the Old Testament Age, the New Testament Age, and the Completed Testament Age. Each age corresponds to a different state of the Spirit World, because what is achieved on earth at each stage of providence determines what becomes possible in the Spirit World.
Old Testament Age. During the era from Adam through the patriarchs and prophets, human beings lived and died without the possibility of entering the Kingdom of Heaven, because the standard of perfected love had not yet been established on earth.
The spirits of faithful Old Testament figures — Abel, Noah, Abraham, Moses, the prophets — gathered in the lower spirit world in a condition of waiting. Jesus referred to this realm as “Abraham’s bosom” (Luke 16:22).
The Fall had separated the human lineage from God; as long as this separation existed at the earthly level, no spirit from the earthly side could ascend to the full presence of God. The entire Spirit World of the Old Testament Age thus remained in a condition of incomplete restoration.
New Testament Age. Jesus came as the substantial embodiment of the Word, the first person in history capable in principle of entering the Kingdom of Heaven as a perfected child of God. Because he was crucified before establishing a Blessed family — before realizing the Second Blessing of God-centered marriage — Jesus himself could not enter the Kingdom of Heaven in its full sense. He ascended to Paradise (Nakwon), the highest realm achievable without the completion of the family-level restoration.
The salvation Jesus opened was spiritual — liberation from original sin at the level of the spirit — but the physical, lineage-level restoration awaited the coming of the Lord of the Second Advent.
The spirit world is the original garden of God’s eternal ideal. Your lifetime on earth is a mere instant. The spirit world, on the other hand, is eternal. Compared to your life in the spirit world, your life on earth is shorter than a breath.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 69-341, 01/03/1974; verified Korean title: 예수가 원하는 크리스마스) Cheon Seong Gyeong
Completed Testament Age. Rev. Moon declared that with the Holy Wedding of True Parents in 1960 and the subsequent providential foundation, the gates of the Kingdom of Heaven were finally opened to human beings for the first time in history.
The standard that had never before been met — a God-centered family of perfected love with restored lineage — was established on earth, and the spiritual foundation for the entire Spirit World to be reorganized accordingly was laid.
The “Blessing of the Spirit World” — extending the Marriage Blessing to spirits — was the institutional expression of this providential reality. The 2000 sermon (천주 통일은 몸 마음의 통일에서부터) names the dynamic structure:
It is important for you to understand the spirit world. What happens when you learn about what your ancestors from thousands of years ago are doing in the spirit world? By understanding clearly that you will inevitably face the same fate, you can transcend difficult problems on this earth. Because I know all this, I do not despair, regardless of what persecution I receive.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 320-245, 04/16/2000; verified Korean title: 천주 통일은 몸 마음의 통일에서부터) Cheon Seong Gyeong
Active Providential Reciprocity: Ancestors and Descendants Move Together
The Unification doctrine of the Spirit World holds, with unusual concreteness, that the spirits of ancestors remain substantively engaged with the lives of their living descendants — praying for them, cooperating with providential movements they participate in, sometimes even sending warnings when descendants stray from the heavenly standard.
This claim, which the Unification movement inherits from the East Asian tradition of ancestor veneration and from Korean shamanic cosmology, is reframed in distinctive Unification terms: ancestors do not simply receive offerings; they actively labor for the providence, and they depend on the living for the substantive work of love-formation that can elevate their spirit selves.
The earliest sermon in the local corpus directly naming 영계 — “기도를 통해 영계를 동원하라” (Mobilize the Spirit World Through Prayer), delivered February 17, 1964, at Daegu Church — already articulates the active-providential-reciprocity claim in compact form:
When you pray, the spirits are mobilized. So in just four years, the spirit world will be mobilized to evangelize, and you will not need to evangelize on your own. Through prayer at the holy ground, you must request that the ancestors cooperate. Korean ancestors did not know Christianity, but they stand in the position of Old Testament Israelite ancestors who were in the position of prophets on earth. Korean descendants living on earth require the cooperation of their own ancestors more than that of prophets from other countries.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 13-020, 02/17/1964; verified Korean title: 기도를 통해 영계를 동원하라) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The 1964 formulation contains in seed the entire mature doctrine of active providential reciprocity. Three points deserve emphasis.
First, ancestors are not passive recipients of prayer; they are mobilized agents of providential work. The verb 동원 (dongwon, mobilize) is military in register: ancestors are recruited, deployed, and given assignments.
Second, the relationship between ancestor and descendant is preferentially particular: a Korean descendant’s own ancestors stand in closer providential relation to that descendant than do prophets or saints from other lineages. The doctrine of universal providence does not erase the substantive particularity of lineage.
Third, the most powerful instrument by which the living engage the Spirit World is prayer — particularly prayer at sacred ground (성지, seongji) — which mobilizes ancestral spirits as cooperators in the providential work being conducted on earth.
The reverse direction of the reciprocity — what spirits in the Spirit World seek from their living descendants — receives one of its sharpest formulations in the 1998 sermon “The Reality of the Spirit World” (영계의 실상), delivered in Brazil on June 1, 1998. The sermon reads from Sang Hun Lee’s messages from the spirit world, and Rev. Moon’s commentary develops the structural logic:
In order to be liberated from their current position, the spirit persons cannot avoid pain without going through people on earth. Since they cannot be freed from their sins, they always seek their earthly dwelling place. They seek out their kin or those related to them and continue to send signs to them.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 293-249, 06/01/1998; verified Korean title: 영계의 실상) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The structural logic is consistent with the earlier-stated principle that change requires the body. Spirits who departed unliberated continue to seek their liberation through the only mechanism available to them — the substantive earthly life of their descendants. They cannot perform indemnity themselves; they can only signal, prompt, and labor providentially through those still in physical bodies.
The signs they send — illnesses, intuitions, providential coincidences, dreams — are their means of communicating to descendants the work still to be done.
The corresponding implication for descendants is striking. Rev. Moon repeatedly insisted that the entire ancestral lineage is “in the hands” of the living person.
The 1973 sermon “The Owners of Heaven and Earth” (하늘땅의 소유자), or the companion “Gathered People” (모인 사람들) — both delivered March 17, 1973 — make the structural point in its most weighty form:
The spirit world is in your hands; your relatives are in your hands — not only your relatives, but even your country is in your hands; even the task of setting the right tradition for your descendants is in your hands. You should always keep this in mind. Whether you, as a single person, accomplish or not, will determine whether your ancestors and relatives will be liberated, and whether your descendants can be the chosen people of liberation.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 66-076, 03/17/1973; verified Korean title: 모인 사람들 / 하늘땅의 소유자) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The weight placed on individual faithfulness here is not, in the Unification reading, a moralistic burden but an honor. The faithful person is the pivot point through whom an entire lineage spanning many generations — both ancestral and descendant — can be drawn toward liberation.
The 1971 sermon “Joyful Workshop” (기쁜 수련회) or its companion “Our Mission and Responsibility” (우리의 사명과 책임), delivered August 13, 1971, makes the macrocosmic claim:
All of you are the historic reincarnations of your ancestors, wearing their faces. The long course of history was eventually to create one person, yourself. In order to create one such person, countless ancestors came and went. Therefore, we are the fruits of human history.
— Sun Myung Moon (Cheon Seong Gyeong 46-155, 08/13/1971; verified Korean title: 기쁜 수련회 / 우리의 사명과 책임) Cheon Seong Gyeong
The teaching transforms the spiritual stakes of ordinary life. To live faithfully is not a private spiritual project; it is participation in a multigenerational community of providential labor stretching backward through history and forward into eternity. The Hebrew Scripture captures this multigenerational sweep of providence in the call of Abraham:
And I will bless them that bless thee, and curse him that curseth thee: and in thee shall all families of the earth be blessed.
The Abrahamic blessing flows through lineage; the merit of the patriarch reaches forward to generations not yet born; and the unfaithfulness of descendants reaches backward to compromise the standing of ancestors.
The Unification doctrine of providential reciprocity reads this multigenerational architecture not merely as a feature of one chosen lineage but as the structural fact about every human person standing as the focal point of an entire ancestral and descendant line.
The Liberation of Hell and the Ultimate Restoration
A distinctive feature of the Unification doctrine of the Spirit World, when read against the broader Christian tradition, is the teaching that Hell is not eternal. The doctrine has three structural commitments.
First, Hell was not created by God as a place of final punishment; it came into being as a consequence of the Fall, and bears no fundamental status in God’s original creation.
Second, Hell is temporary in the providential horizon: the redemptive work of the Messiah extends to all spirits, including those currently in the lowest realm.
,Third, the liberation of Hell is one of the central purposes of the Completed Testament Age providence and of the work of True Parents.
This teaching distinguishes Unification doctrine from the mainstream Christian tradition that holds Hell to be eternal in some strong sense — whether the eternal conscious torment of the Augustinian-Reformed tradition or the eternal annihilation of certain conditional-immortality positions. It aligns more closely with patristic universalist readings (Origen, Gregory of Nyssa), with the Kabbalistic doctrine of the eventual return of all sparks to their source, and with certain currents in Mahayana Buddhism that promise the liberation of all sentient beings. But the Unification doctrine articulates the liberation thesis in distinctive terms: Hell is not liberated by divine fiat but through the providential labor of True Parents and their substantive engagement with the realm of fallen spirits.
The pastoral implication of this teaching is significant. The Unification movement does not preach Hell as a threat held over the believer; it preaches Hell as a condition to be liberated.
The work of every member is, in part, the work of liberating ancestors from Hell, not the work of avoiding Hell oneself by performance of religious obligations. The orientation is constructive rather than defensive.
The temporal scope of this liberation work is, however, considerable. The 1992 sermon makes the point soberly:
“If you pass to the spirit world without overcoming this in your lifetime, there is no way to know how many millions of years it will take you in the spirit world” (April 12, 1992).
Hell is liberable but not instantly liberated; the work is providential and proceeds across long horizons.
The Seunghwa Ceremony: The Threshold Between Worlds
The transition from the physical world to the Spirit World is marked, in Unification practice, by the Seunghwa Ceremony (성화식, Seonghwasik), literally “ceremony of sacred ascension and blossoming.” The word Seunghwa (昇華) is the Sino-Korean equivalent of the chemical term “sublimation” — the direct transition of a substance from solid to gas without passing through the liquid phase — but Rev. Moon used it precisely because the conceptual content carried over: at the moment of physical death, the spirit self transitions directly from earthly embodiment to Spirit-World life, with no intermediate stage of “soul-sleep” or unconscious waiting.
Rev. Moon instituted the Seunghwa Ceremony following the passing of his second son, Heung Jin Nim, in 1984, teaching that death rightly understood is not a tragedy but a graduation — the spirit’s entry into its true and eternal home.
Members are taught to attend the Seunghwa Ceremony not with grief and mourning but with a spirit of joyful sending-forth, supporting the ascending spirit with love, prayer, and song. The understanding is that excessive grief on the part of the living can actually impede the ascending spirit, pulling it back with the weight of earthly attachment. True love releases; it does not cling.
The full development of the Seunghwa rite — its theological significance, its ritual structure, its differences from conventional funerals — is treated in the dedicated glossary entry on Seunghwa Ceremony.
For present purposes, the relevant structural point is that the Seunghwa Ceremony makes the Unification doctrine of the Spirit World pastorally concrete: the moment of physical death is marked by a specific rite that publicly affirms continuity of the spirit self, transition into the Spirit World, and the substantive engagement of the surviving family with the providential work the departed will now undertake in the Spirit World mode.
Cheon Il Guk: The Convergence of Spirit World and Earth
In the final phase of his teaching, Rev. Moon increasingly spoke of Cheon Il Guk (천일국, 天一國) — the Kingdom of Heaven on Earth — as the goal toward which all of history had been moving. Cheon Il Guk is not merely the Spirit World “coming down” to earth; it is the condition in which the physical and spiritual dimensions of the cosmos are finally unified, with God dwelling as the True Parent of all humanity and every family on earth becoming a substantive cell of the heavenly kingdom.
The relationship between the Spirit World and Cheon Il Guk is therefore not one of succession — where earth is eventually replaced by heaven — but of convergence: the physical world, fully restored and fully centered on God’s love, becomes the substantive foundation for the eternal Spirit World, and the two realms together constitute the completed cosmos that God originally intended at the moment of creation.
The Spirit-World-and-Earth-Are-One claim, articulated in the 2002 sermon discussed earlier, finds its eschatological fulfillment here: the two worlds, originally one in intention but divided by the Fall, are finally reunited in actual reality.
This eschatological convergence has practical implications for Blessed Family life.
The Blessed Family on earth, living according to the Three Great Blessings and oriented toward Cheon Il Guk, is not merely preparing for a future heaven but substantively participating, in this earthly life, in the convergence of the spirit world and earth. The full elaboration is treated in the glossary entries on Cheon Il Guk and Kingdom of Heaven.
Interreligious Resonance
The Unification doctrine of the Spirit World has parallels in every major religious tradition — sometimes in striking detail. The comparison illuminates both where Unification teaching resonates with prior wisdom and where it offers a distinctive contribution.
Christianity. The biblical account of life after death is structurally heterogeneous, containing Sheol tradition (the shadowy dwelling of all the dead before the resurrection), Pauline spiritual-body tradition (1 Corinthians 15), the Lukan parable of Lazarus and the rich man (Luke 16), the apocalyptic resurrection-of-the-dead tradition (Daniel 12, Revelation 20), and the Johannine eternal-life tradition (John 17:3).
The mainstream Christian theological synthesis, especially in the Catholic tradition since the High Middle Ages, has organized these elements around a structured afterlife of Heaven, Purgatory, and Hell, with placement determined primarily by the state of the soul in relation to grace at the moment of death.
The Unification framework shares the structural commitment to a graded afterlife and the absolute importance of earthly life for determining one’s eternal condition, but differs significantly in three respects: it places the family rather than the individual at the center of the afterlife (one cannot enter the Kingdom of Heaven alone); it holds the Spirit World to be dynamic, in continuous reorganization through providential events on earth; and it denies that any realm is permanently sealed, holding even Hell to be temporary in the eschatological horizon.
The Pauline doctrine of the spiritual body in 1 Corinthians 15 provides the closest Christian structural parallel to the Unification account: a substantive bodily continuation of the same person across the death-resurrection transition, distinct from both Greek immortal-soul doctrine and from materialist denial.
The principal divergence is temporal: Paul locates the appearance of the spiritual body at a future general resurrection, while Unification doctrine locates it at the moment of each individual’s physical death.
Judaism. The Hebrew Bible’s account of death centers on Sheol (שְׁאוֹל), the shadowy underworld where all the dead descend. This early conception developed considerably in rabbinical and later Jewish thought into the framework of Olam Ha-Ba (עוֹלָם הַבָּא, “the World to Come”) and Gehinnom (גֵּיהִנֹּם, a purgatorial realm of refinement from which most souls eventually ascend).
The Kabbalistic tradition further develops a multidimensional cosmology of spiritual worlds (olamot). Unification doctrine shares with the Kabbalistic tradition the sense of the Spirit World as a multidimensional cosmos with its own internal structure and laws and with rabbinical tradition the conviction that the living can perform acts (mitzvot, Torah study, prayer) that benefit the souls of the departed — a principle structurally parallel to the Unification doctrine of ancestor liberation.
Islam. Islam teaches a detailed account of the afterlife: the Barzakh (برزخ, the “barrier”) as the intermediate realm between death and the Final Judgment; the Day of Resurrection (Yawm al-Qiyāmah); and the final destinations of Jannah (Paradise) and Jahannam (Hell). The Quranic emphasis on detailed earthly accountability resonates strongly with the Unification transparency teaching:
And whoso doeth good an atom’s weight will see it then, And whoso doeth ill an atom’s weight will see it then.
The Quranic teaching that even an atom’s weight of good or ill will be seen at the moment of revelation is structurally close to the Unification claim that every action is recorded in the conscience and revealed in the Spirit World.
The principal divergence is the Islamic location of decisive judgment at a single eschatological event versus the Unification location of disclosure at each individual’s physical death.
Buddhism. Buddhist cosmology describes an elaborate series of realms (lokas) organized according to the karmic level of beings, through which consciousness transmigrates across many lives.
The Unification doctrine explicitly rejects metempsychosis, holding that each human spirit makes the transition to the Spirit World only once. It does share with Buddhism, however, the emphasis on the quality of one’s inner life as the determinant of the after-death condition and the recognition that the post-mortem cosmos has its complex internal structure.
The Mahayana doctrine of the bodhisattva — the enlightened being who postpones final liberation to assist others toward enlightenment — has a structural parallel in the Unification figure of the ancestor laboring providentially from the Spirit World for the liberation of descendants and the broader spirit-world community.
Confucianism and Korean Tradition. The Unification teaching on the active relationship between the living and the departed resonates deeply with the Korean cultural context in which Rev. Moon’s ministry was formed. Korean shamanism (musok, 무속) centers on communication between the living and the spirits of the departed — particularly ancestors — through ritual mediation.
The Confucian tradition of jesa (제사, ancestral rites) maintains that departed ancestors remain present to the family and are honored through regular offerings. Rev. Moon both honored and transformed these traditions: the ancestors are real, present, and active (affirming the shamanic and Confucian intuition), but the governing principle of their relationship with the living is not ritual propitiation but providential alignment with God’s will through the Blessing.
The Korean cultural conviction that the living and the dead form a single ongoing community of obligation finds in Unification theology its universalized and Christianized articulation.
The classical Confucian text The Doctrine of the Mean (Zhongyong, 中庸) gives the foundational structural claim that recurs in Unification doctrine:
How abundantly do spiritual beings display the powers that belong to them! We look for them, but do not see them; we listen to, but do not hear them; yet they enter into all things, and there is nothing without them.
The Confucian claim that spirits “enter into all things” and that “there is nothing without them” — invisible to ordinary perception but substantively present and active — articulates the ontological-continuity thesis in classical Chinese register. Unification doctrine inherits and develops this conviction.
Analytical Synthesis: Discontinuous Afterlife or Continuous Cosmos?
The thesis advanced in this entry — that the Spirit World in Unification doctrine is the invisible co-dimension of a single continuum of being, marked by ontological continuity, absolute transparency, and active providential reciprocity — faces a serious alternative reading within the broader theological landscape, and one that some sympathetic Christian readers occasionally propose in dialogue with the Unification movement.
The alternative reading holds that the Spirit World should be understood, in the end, as a discontinuous afterlife — an “other world” separated from the present by the absolute boundary of death, in which the consequences of earthly life are received but in which the living have no substantive role to play.
On this reading, the Unification language of mirror movement, providential reciprocity, and ancestor liberation should be understood as devotional rhetoric expressing the seriousness with which the movement takes the afterlife, not as ontological claims about a present-and-active reality.
The Spirit World, on this reading, is a future destination, and the living should focus on their preparation for that destination rather than on supposed two-way traffic with deceased ancestors.
The alternative reading has internal plausibility. It aligns the Unification doctrine more closely with Protestant Christian eschatology, avoids commitments that some critics find metaphysically extravagant, and dampens claims about contact with the dead that Western theological liberalism has typically found difficult. It can cite certain Pauline texts (especially 1 Timothy 2:5 on Christ as the sole mediator) as a theological warrant for limiting traffic across the threshold of death.
But the alternative reading cannot, in the end, be sustained against the textual evidence. Four considerations make the continuity-and-reciprocity reading clearly preferred.
First, the textual insistence on continuity is unequivocal. The 1977 sermon “영계와 육계,” the 1982 sermon “하나님의 존전 앞에서,” the 1991 lecture “전미 지도자 회의 지시 말씀,” and the 2002 sermon “영계와 지상세계는 하나” are not isolated formulations: they articulate a sustained doctrinal position across three decades, with the language of ontological unity (둘이 아니라 하나 — “not two but one”) deployed repeatedly and emphatically. The discontinuous-afterlife reading must repeatedly explain away textual claims that resist symbolic reduction.
Second, the active reciprocity teaching is foundational to Unification practice. Ancestor liberation ceremonies, prayer at sacred ground, the mobilization of the spirit world through faithful living, and the Blessing of the Spirit World — these are not peripheral devotional practices but constitutive elements of Unification religious life. To reduce them to symbolic rhetoric is to misunderstand their substantive doctrinal grounding.
Third, the transparency teaching presupposes substantive continuity. The doctrine that every earthly event is recorded in the conscience and displayed in the Spirit World requires that the Spirit World be the kind of place where such records can substantively exist and be displayed. A merely symbolic or rhetorical Spirit World cannot bear the doctrinal weight of the transparency teaching. The substantive ontology is required.
Fourth, the continuity-and-reciprocity reading does important conceptual work that the discontinuous-afterlife reading cannot. The Unification account of providence as ongoing through both worlds, of the Messiah’s work as extending substantively to spirits as well as the living, of the Blessing as transforming both the earthly and spirit-world dimensions of the cosmos — all of these require continuity and reciprocity. They are not optional decorations on a familiar afterlife doctrine; they are the doctrine’s working architecture.
The continuity-and-reciprocity reading does carry one important caveat. The “continuity” of the two worlds is not a continuity of substance in the modern scientific sense.
The Spirit World does not occupy ordinary physical space and does not interact with the physical world in the way one material object interacts with another. Its substance is spiritual — composed of love elements, perceptible to spiritual senses, operative within its own distinctive ontology.
The continuity-and-reciprocity reading is therefore not a claim about empirically discoverable interactions but a claim about a substantive reality of a different ontological order, which Unification doctrine holds to be the more original and more real of the two orders, of which the physical world is itself a derivative reflection.
The thesis stands: the Spirit World is the invisible co-dimension of a single continuum of being, marked by ontological continuity, absolute transparency, and active providential reciprocity. To read it otherwise is to collapse Unification doctrine into a familiar variant of Protestant eschatology and to lose the distinctive teaching that makes it doctrinally fruitful.
Key Takeaway
- The Spirit World (영계) is not a discontinuous “other world” but the invisible co-dimension of a single continuum of being, ontologically continuous with the physical world (육계) and in constant reciprocal action with it.
- The Spirit World records every earthly event with absolute transparency: there is no editing, no concealment, and no possibility of presenting a curated version of one’s life — the conscience is the recording mechanism, and its archive is displayed at the moment of physical death.
- The Spirit World is organized by the quality of love each spirit has lived, not by geography, chronology, or social rank — and movement within it is measured in love rather than spatial distance.
- The Spirit World is structurally isomorphic to the human person: a fully realized person is a microcosm of the Spirit World, and the Spirit World is the macrocosm of the perfected person.
- Change requires the body: indemnity, repentance, and substantive transformation can be accomplished only during earthly life, and once a spirit is fixed in its post-mortem position, change can come only through the substantive labor of living descendants.
- Active providential reciprocity is constitutive: ancestors substantively mobilize the living through prayer and providential events, while the living substantively liberate the dead through ancestor liberation, the Blessing, and faithful Hoon Dok Hae life.
- Hell is not eternal: it came into being through the Fall and is destined for liberation through the providence of restoration; Unification doctrine reads the Spirit World’s ultimate horizon as universal restoration, not permanent division.
- The Spirit World and the physical world converge eschatologically in Cheon Il Guk — the Kingdom of Heaven on Earth — in which the two dimensions of the cosmos are finally reunified as God originally intended.
Related Questions
Is the Spirit World the same as “the afterlife” in popular Christian usage?
Not quite. Popular Christian usage often treats “the afterlife” as a separate world entered after death, sealed off from the present.
Unification doctrine holds that the Spirit World is the invisible co-dimension of the same continuum of being one already inhabits — a dimension that interpenetrates the physical world at every point and is in continuous reciprocal action with it. The Spirit World is not where one goes after death; it is the deeper dimension of the reality one is in.
Does the doctrine of “no editing” mean every minor failure will be exposed?
The doctrine teaches that the conscience records continuously, and the record is displayed fully at the moment of physical death. The doctrine does not, however, treat all recorded actions as having equal weight. Major commitments and major failures bear major weight; minor failings, especially those repented and indemnified during earthly life, are correspondingly less weighty in the appraisal.
The point of the doctrine is not to produce anxiety about every small slip but to overturn the assumption that anything significant can be hidden. What is recorded is recorded; what is unrepentant remains in the record uncorrected.
Can the dead help the living, or can only the living help the dead?
The reciprocity runs in both directions, with different mechanisms. The living help the dead substantively through indemnity conditions, prayer, the Blessing, and ancestor liberation ceremonies — these are the substantive mechanisms by which spirits in the Spirit World can be elevated to higher realms.
The dead help the living providentially through prayer offered for the living, providential cooperation with the living’s mission, and the sending of signs and warnings when the living stray from the heavenly standard. The mechanisms differ because the modes of being differ, but the reciprocity is real.
What happens to people from other religions or with no religion in the Spirit World?
The Unification doctrine of the Spirit World is universalist in scope but not relativist in standard. Every human spirit goes to the Spirit World; placement is determined by the quality of love actually lived, not by religious affiliation. A devoted Muslim, a sincere Buddhist, an atheist who lived a life of substantive love for others — all are received into the Spirit World, and their placement reflects the love formation their earthly life accomplished.
The work of the Completed Testament Age — including the Blessing of spirits from other religious traditions — extends the substantive transformation that True Parents introduced to all humanity, not only to Unification members.
Is contact with departed family members possible?
The Unification doctrine holds that real contact across the threshold is possible, although ordinary perception in the fallen condition typically does not register it directly. Such contact is most often mediated by dreams, intuitions, sudden providential coincidences, and the gentle prompting of conscience — rather than by overt apparitions.
Some members of the movement report more vivid experiences. The doctrinal position is that the reality of contact is constant; the question is whether and how the living person can become substantively aware of what is constantly occurring.
References
Cheon Seong Gyeong: Selections from the Speeches of Sun Myung Moon. 2003.
Exposition of the Divine Principle. 1996. New York: Holy Spirit Association for the Unification of World Christianity.
Lee Sang Hun. Life in the Spirit World and on Earth: Messages from the Spirit World. 1998-2002. Messages communicated through Young Soon Kim and published with the endorsement of Rev. Sun Myung Moon. (Source of the “영계의 실상” sermon series, 1998-2008.)
Moon, Sun Myung. “기도를 통해 영계를 동원하라” Sermon delivered February 17, 1964, at Daegu Church.
Moon, Sun Myung. “영계와 육계” (Spirit World and Physical World). Sermon delivered February 6, 1977, at Belvedere Training Center.
Moon, Sun Myung. “영계의 실상.” Sermon delivered June 1, 1998, at the Pantanal, Brazil.
Moon, Sun Myung. “영계와 지상세계는 하나” 21, 2002, in Kodiak, Alaska.
Editorial Note. This entry is a scholarly-edition upgrade of an earlier Spirit World glossary entry, undertaken to bring the entry into conformity with the current scholarly-edition standards adopted across the glossary. Four substantive changes have been made.